Ultimate guide to preparing for an Oliver Wyman case interview
Oliver Wyman’s doors swing open for just 3-4% of those who knock. Daunting? Absolutely. Insurmountable? Not even close. This consulting firm sets standards high, yet with thoughtful preparation, you can rise to meet them.
This guide illuminates Oliver Wyman’s selection process with fresh insights for 2025. From first interview to final offer, we’ll navigate each step together—breaking down what they’re searching for and equipping you with strategies to showcase your best self when it counts most.
Structure of the guide
- How is the selection process at Oliver Wyman structured?
- What are the components of an Oliver Wyman interview?
- How do Oliver Wyman interviews differ from other consulting firms?
- What types of cases can you expect at Oliver Wyman?
- What can you expect in the FIT portion of an Oliver Wyman interview?
- How do you approach preparing for an Oliver Wyman case interview?
Why this guide is different
Forget generic interview advice. This resource targets Oliver Wyman’s specific approach and unique expectations. Whether you’re sketching your first preparation outline or applying final polish before the big day, you’ll discover practical tools tailored to Oliver Wyman’s distinctive evaluation style—tools that can transform a potential rejection into a welcome aboard.
How is the selection process at Oliver Wyman structured?
Understanding what sets Oliver Wyman apart helps you prepare with precision. Here’s how they compare to other consulting firms:
| Criteria | Oliver Wyman | Tier 1 firms (McKinsey, BCG, Bain) | Other Tier 2 firms (Strategy&, Roland Berger, etc.) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Interview format |
Candidate-led with strong quantitative focus |
McKinsey: Interviewer-led; BCG/Bain: Candidate-led |
Varies by firm; typically candidate-led with less quantitative emphasis |
|
Interviewer role |
Acts as client, emphasizes data-driven insights |
McKinsey: Actively guides; BCG/Bain: Acts as client |
Usually similar to BCG/Bain but less standardized |
|
Case structure |
Heavy emphasis on quantitative analysis and financial modeling |
Broader mix of qualitative and quantitative elements |
Often more qualitative with some quantitative elements |
|
Evaluation process |
Strong focus on numerical aptitude and analytical precision |
McKinsey: Standardized checklists; BCG/Bain: Structured evaluation |
Usually less standardized assessment |
|
Number of rounds |
Two to three rounds |
Typically two rounds |
Typically two rounds, sometimes three |
|
Interviews per round |
Two to three interviews per round |
Two to three interviews per round |
Usually two interviews per round |
|
Common industries |
Strong focus on financial services, retail, healthcare, and digital |
Broader coverage across industries |
Often specialized by firm (e.g., Roland Berger: automotive and industrial) |
What are the components of an Oliver Wyman interview?
An Oliver Wyman interview unfolds in three distinct parts. Each examines different aspects of your potential fit with the firm.
Personal fit interview
Through carefully crafted questions about your past experiences, Oliver Wyman explores four essential qualities:
- Analytical excellence: How do you tackle complex problems? They watch for your ability to break down complicated challenges into manageable pieces and apply numerical reasoning. Simple questions often reveal profound thinking patterns.
- Industry insight: Do you grasp the fundamentals of financial services, retail, or healthcare? While they don’t expect expert knowledge, Oliver Wyman values candidates who bring some industry awareness to the table—a base they can build upon.
- Client impact: Have your past efforts created tangible results? Theory matters less than practical impact here. They seek people who don’t just identify problems but drive real solutions forward.
- Team collaboration: Can you work effectively with diverse groups? Consulting demands seamless teamwork across different personalities, backgrounds, and stakeholder priorities—a skill best demonstrated through specific examples rather than general claims.
This approach helps them assess your alignment with their culture, where analytical precision meets practical problem-solving.
Case interview
For 40-45 minutes—the interview’s core—you’ll tackle a business problem that reflects Oliver Wyman’s distinctive style:
- You’ll encounter more detailed numerical data than at other consulting firms
- Financial analysis plays a central role, often requiring comfort with basic calculations
- You must drive the entire process yourself, forming hypotheses and testing them with data
- Practical, implementable recommendations matter more than theoretical insights
- Cases frequently center on specific industries, with financial services appearing most often
This section tests your quantitative comfort alongside your strategic thinking—a combination Oliver Wyman particularly prizes. Numbers tell stories here; your job is to interpret them correctly.
Your questions for the interviewer
As the case concludes, roles reverse. Now you ask the questions—a moment that carries more weight than many candidates realize. Oliver Wyman values questions that demonstrate understanding of their analytical approach and industry specializations. Thoughtful inquiries here sometimes tip the scales for candidates on the bubble.
While virtual interviews became common in recent years, Oliver Wyman now employs a hybrid approach. Early rounds may occur online, but final interviews typically take place in their offices. This balance gives you a glimpse of their work environment while providing flexibility in preliminary stages.
How do Oliver Wyman interviews differ from other consulting firms?
Many promising candidates stumble at a basic hurdle: they prepare for generic consulting interviews rather than Oliver Wyman’s specific approach. This misalignment often leads directly to rejection.
Oliver Wyman follows a candidate-led format similar to BCG and Bain but with a significantly heavier emphasis on quantitative analysis and financial understanding. This reflects their heritage in financial services consulting and their data-driven approach to client problems.
In their interview structure, you control the case from start to finish. You pose the questions, request specific data, analyze the information, and deliver recommendations. The interviewer observes your process rather than guiding you through predefined steps—more client than teacher.
This approach transforms how you should handle case openings:
When facing an Oliver Wyman case, you might say: “To understand this retail banking profitability challenge, I’d like to explore three key areas: revenue drivers, cost structure, and competitive positioning. Could we start by looking at the bank’s financial performance over recent years? This would help me identify where the profitability issues are most severe.”
This response demonstrates structured thinking alongside a focus on quantitative analysis—precisely what Oliver Wyman seeks in candidates.
Oliver Wyman distinguishes itself in several crucial ways:
- Quantitative depth: Expect more complex calculations and deeper financial analysis than at other firms
- Industry specificity: Cases concentrate on financial services, retail, and healthcare scenarios where Oliver Wyman has particular expertise
- Data interpretation: You’ll need to extract insights from complex datasets and visualizations
- Technical elements: Cases might incorporate specialized topics like risk assessment or digital transformation
Understanding these distinctions matters tremendously for success. Oliver Wyman seeks candidates who blend strong numerical skills with strategic thinking and industry awareness—a rare combination they’re willing to reward handsomely.
Case Types to Expect at Oliver Wyman
Excelling in Oliver Wyman case interviews requires strong analytical capabilities and the ability to apply structured thinking with creativity and precision, which Oliver Wyman particularly values. Successful candidates typically navigate through these critical areas:
Key Steps in Solving a Case
- Clarifying questions – After receiving the case prompt, ask targeted questions to better understand the client’s problem and objectives before structuring your approach.
- Structuring – Choose a relevant framework and adapt it to the specific problem and industry, with particular attention to financial services contexts.
- Analyzing graphical data – Identify trends in the provided charts and interpret their implications for the client’s problem.
- Solving the math problem – Perform calculations and interpret the results within the context of the case.
- Providing recommendations – Conduct a structured brainstorming session to offer actionable solutions, considering the client’s objectives and constraints.
Common Types of Business Problems Tested
Quantitative Structures
- Market sizing: What’s the potential market for blockchain-based payment solutions among mid-tier financial institutions in Western Europe?
Here is an example of a marketsizing exercise that you can encounter
https://youtu.be/U5GLsH1kAdM?si=BgChqTcSHbO8bfB0
https://youtu.be/zv_IYKZkyUc?si=mLQluaOkDeUM9rkr
- Profit and Loss (P&L): A major retail bank has increased its digital product offerings, yet its cost-to-income ratio continues to rise—what factors are driving this?
Qualitative Structures
- Growth strategy: How should a leading insurance provider diversify its product portfolio to mitigate impacts of climate change on its business model?
- Market entry: Should an established European asset management firm expand into the growing wealth management market in Southeast Asia?
- Pricing: What risk-based pricing approach would optimize profitability while maintaining competitiveness for this new credit card offering?
- Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A): Would acquiring this fintech startup enhance our banking client’s digital transformation journey or present integration challenges?
- Capacity expansion: Should our healthcare client invest in additional specialty clinics or pursue strategic partnerships? The decision requires thorough analysis of multiple factors.
- Public sector strategies: Design a financial inclusion strategy for an emerging market economy.
Process-oriented Structures
- Operational cases: Risk management processes at our client’s trading division have shown increasing control failures—identify root causes and solutions.
- Customer journey cases: Digital engagement metrics for a wealth management platform have plateaued despite increased feature development. Why?
- Unique public sector processes: A national health insurance program has seen declining participation rates despite expanded benefits. What’s driving this trend?
Industry Knowledge
Beyond mastering various case types, familiarize yourself with key industries where Oliver Wyman demonstrates particular strength: financial services (banking, insurance, wealth management), retail, healthcare, and digital businesses. Their cases frequently reflect these sectors, mirroring their strong market position in these areas.
Oliver Wyman regularly weaves elements of risk management, digital transformation, and financial analysis into their cases. Familiarity with these concepts can give you a significant advantage when facing their interviewers.
By following a structured approach and understanding these diverse business scenarios, you’ll be thoroughly prepared for the wide range of cases Oliver Wyman might present during your interviews.
Are You Ready for a Career a Top Company?
Answer three questions and get a personalized breakdown.
What Can You Expect in the FIT Portion of an Oliver Wyman Interview?
The FIT portion carries equal weight to the case interview, as it assesses your personal values, motivations, and experiences to ensure alignment with the firm’s distinctive culture. This section typically explores three question categories:
“Tell me about yourself and your professional journey”
You’ll need to provide a concise yet comprehensive overview of your background, highlighting experiences directly relevant to consulting and Oliver Wyman’s values. They particularly appreciate candidates who can articulate how their quantitative abilities and industry interests align perfectly with the firm’s specialized focus areas.
Motivation questions
Interviewers will probe why you’re pursuing consulting and why Oliver Wyman specifically draws your interest. Be prepared to explain precisely what attracts you to their culture, values, and industry focus. Unlike other firms, Oliver Wyman places special emphasis on your understanding of their analytical methodology and industry specializations, particularly in financial services, retail, and healthcare.
Behavioral questions
This represents the most critical component of the FIT section, where you’ll share stories demonstrating specific skills and values:
- Analytical excellence: Describe a time when you approached a complex quantitative problem and extracted actionable insights that others missed.
- Industry knowledge: Show your understanding of key sectors where Oliver Wyman operates, particularly financial services and its subsectors.
- Client impact: Explain how you’ve delivered tangible, measurable results for stakeholders in previous roles.
- Team collaboration: Illustrate your ability to work effectively within diverse teams and navigate complex stakeholder relationships.
- Learning agility: Share how you’ve rapidly adapted to unfamiliar industries or technical concepts, reflecting Oliver Wyman’s emphasis on intellectual curiosity.
Preparing Your Stories
Begin crafting these stories 2-3 weeks before your interview, ensuring they precisely meet Oliver Wyman’s specific criteria for each category. Each narrative should run 3-4 minutes and follow the STAR framework (Situation, Task, Action, Result), with approximately 70% focusing on your specific actions and the measurable impact you created.
Oliver Wyman interviewers typically value stories showcasing quantitative abilities and industry knowledge more highly than general leadership examples, so ensure your examples highlight these dimensions wherever possible.
How Do You Approach Preparing for an Oliver Wyman Case Interview?
Preparing effectively for an Oliver Wyman case interview demands a disciplined, structured approach. Here are the essential preparation stages:
1. Setting a Clear Goal
A well-defined goal serves as the foundation of effective preparation. Without a precise objective, you risk losing focus and motivation during the demanding preparation process. Knowing that securing an offer is your ultimate aim will fuel your consistency throughout. For Oliver Wyman specifically, understand that your preparation must emphasize quantitative excellence and deep industry knowledge more than at other firms.
2. Creating a Study Schedule
Consistency trumps intensity in case preparation. Allocate time daily based on your available preparation window:
- 3 months: 45 minutes of focused study per day
- 1.5 months: 1.5 hours of concentrated work daily
- 1 month: 2 hours of intensive preparation each day
For Oliver Wyman specifically, dedicate additional time to strengthening your quantitative skills and understanding financial services concepts, as these represent critical success factors in their uniquely challenging cases.
3. Mastering Case Interview Theory
Before diving into practice cases, build a rock-solid theoretical foundation. Cover all critical aspects of case-solving methodology, including:
- Key steps for tackling quantitatively complex cases
- Various case types (quantitative, qualitative, and process-oriented)
- Industry-specific nuances (financial services, retail, healthcare)
- Financial analysis concepts and calculation methods
Dedicate specific days to each theoretical block to avoid overwhelming yourself. Pay particular attention to financial metrics, risk analysis frameworks, and digital transformation concepts that frequently appear in Oliver Wyman cases.
4. Practicing Case Interviews
There’s simply no substitute for practice. Aim to solve at least 50-80 cases before your interview, focusing on feedback and continuous improvement rather than just quantity. For Oliver Wyman specifically:
- Emphasize cases featuring complex numerical components
- Practice financial analysis and modeling regularly
- Build comfort with interpreting sophisticated data visualizations
- Focus on financial services, retail, and healthcare scenarios
- Develop industry-specific vocabulary and conceptual frameworks
Work with experienced candidates or professional case coaches to ensure the feedback you receive is actionable and high-quality. For Oliver Wyman preparation, prioritize practice partners who can accurately simulate their quantitatively rigorous, industry-specific interview style.
5. Preparing the FIT Portion
Craft your personal stories following Oliver Wyman’s specific requirements. Use the STAR framework to structure each narrative (Situation, Task, Action, Result), ensuring they run 3-4 minutes and address the core values Oliver Wyman seeks:
- Analytical excellence
- Industry knowledge
- Client impact
- Team collaboration
- Learning agility
Prepare compelling examples that showcase your quantitative abilities and industry awareness, as these qualities are particularly valued by Oliver Wyman interviewers more than general leadership stories.
By following this structured approach tailored to Oliver Wyman’s specific interview format and values, you’ll develop the skills, confidence, and readiness to excel in their rigorous selection process.